Call for paid service +44 (0)344-991-9222

French proposal on immigration divides EU

Watch This Video

A French proposal to ban massive amnesties to illegal immigrants divided the European Union Sept. 30 in Madrid, where foreign and interior ministers from eight Mediterranean countries met to stem the mounting influx of migrants into southern Europe.

French Interior Minister Nicolas Sarkozy is seeking a European immigration pact including a ban on massive amnesties such as the one carried out last year by the Spanish government, which gave residence permits to more than half a million undocumented immigrants.

Sarkozy said he expected the meeting to back his proposal because massive amnesties had a negative impact throughout the EU. But European Justice and Home Affairs Commissioner Franco Frattini said he did not believe that amnesties could be prohibited by law.

Spanish Prime Minister Jose Luis Rodriguez Zapatero had earlier engaged in a war of words with Sarkozy, saying Spain had no "lessons" to receive from France where immigrants staged massive riots in Paris suburbs last year.

Spanish ministers stressed the need for a common European immigration policy to deal with what was not just a Spanish, but also a European problem.

Foreign Minister Miguel Angel Moratinos called for solidarity with southern European countries, which formed the EU's common southern frontier, while Interior Minister Alfredo Perez Rubalcaba emphasized the need for a common policy in expelling illegal immigrants back to their countries.

Spain has repatriated more than 1,000 Senegalese in the past few weeks and intends to expel 1,200 more, but many African countries are reluctant to accept repatriations because of their unpopularity.

The meeting followed an urgent appeal from Spain after the arrival of some 23,000 Africans in the Canary Islands this year, bringing reception structures near collapse.

Participants included Spain, France, Portugal, Italy, Greece, Malta, Cyprus, Slovenia, European Justice and Home Affairs Commissioner Franco Frattini, External Relations Commissioner Benita Ferrero-Waldner and a representative of the Finnish EU presidency.

The countries were expected to prepare proposals for the October 20 informal EU summit in the Finnish city of Lahti, including the reinforcement of the European border control agency Frontex, which has only been able to stage small-scale patrols on the Mediterranean and off West Africa.

Spain's appeals for financial and other help have the backing of other southern countries such as Italy, Malta and Greece, which are also receiving immigrants from Africa and Turkey. Italian coastal patrols have intercepted at least 16,000 illegals this year, according to government figures.

Yet other European countries, such as Germany, Austria and the Netherlands, are reluctant to grant Spain more funds. France has joined them in accusing Madrid of partially creating its immigration problem by legalizing large numbers of illegals.

"It is not easy" to achieve a common EU immigration policy, which required "the will of the member countries," Ferrero-Waldner said.

Planned EU patrols to intercept immigrant boats have got off to a modest start, with mainly just Spain, Portugal and Italy contributing some boats and a few airplanes to Frontex for the purpose.

Frontex has nevertheless intercepted more than 50 immigrant boats with some 2,500 passengers over the past few months, Deputy Prime Minister Maria Teresa Fernandez de la Vega said.

Increased police cooperation with African countries has given even better results, with Mauritania and Senegal preventing the departure of some 10,000 migrants in a few weeks, according to Vega.

Spain and other countries meeting in Madrid want the EU to dedicate a substantial part of its 2007-2013 frontier control budget of 2.3 billion dollars to the southern border.

Spain feels that EU regulations neglect maritime borders, focusing on land borders and airports.

Spain, France, Cyprus, Italy, Greece, Malta, Portugal and Slovenia wrote to European Commission President Jose Manuel Barroso prior to the meeting, stressing that the problem of illegal immigration was too big for any country to handle alone.

Spain has pointed out that most of the Africans arriving in the Canaries are French-speakers traveling to other European countries.

More migrants meanwhile continued arriving in the Canary Islands, with a total of around 120 landing on Tenerife and Lanzarote Sept. 30.

Africans make up a relatively small part of an estimated one million undocumented immigrants in Spain, but they are attracting the most attention because of their dangerous sea journeys of more than 1,000 kilometers from Senegal or Guinea-Bissau.

Refugee boats frequently capsize, and up to 3,000 migrants are estimated to have drowned this year.

Related:

EU Ministers to discuss illegal immigration solution
Spain to patrol coast of Senegal to control illegal migration
1,000 Africans arrive in Spanish Canary Islands in one day

Spain, France, Italy to make joint migration proposal

Canary Islands President demands urgent action on illegal immigration
EU and Africa meet to discuss migration problems
African migrants attempt entry into the EU via Mediterranean

EU launches marine border squad
EU to invest in development of Africa to slow immigration